Was haig a butcher or war

Haig maintained that the battle achieved the goal of eroding the German Army and its will to fight. Haig attended a Cabinet meeting in London 15 April where the politicians were more concerned with the political crisis over the introduction of conscription, which could bring down the government Was haig a butcher or war Haig recorded that Asquith attended the meeting dressed for golf and clearly keen to get away for the weekend.

Almost a decade after the war, Haig still believed in the use of cavalry: French wrote to Joffre saying he was willing to go along with these plans for the sake of Anglo-French cooperation, but then wrote to Joffre again 10 August suggesting an artillery bombardment with only limited British infantry attacks.

On 29 JanuaryDouglas Haig died from a heart attack brought on, according to his widow, by the strain of wartime command.

An expert horseman, he once represented England at polo. He complained privately of French unreliability and lack of fighting competence, a complaint which he would keep up for the next four years. Joffre was not pleased and called another conference 11 July to urge a British attack on Loos.

Haig was intolerant of what he regarded as old-fashioned opinion and not good at negotiating with strangers. Casualties were around 12, on each side. The two corps were supposed to meet at Le Cateau but I Corps under Haig were stopped at Landreciesleaving a large gap between the two corps.

British soldiers transport a wounded colleague on a wheeled stretcher during the Battle of the Somme. Rumours were rife that French was to be sacked, another reason given for sacking him, was that his shortcomings would become more pronounced with the expansion of the BEF, which would number sixty divisions within two years.

The battle to defend Paris began on 5 September and became known as the first Battle of the Marne. Over the course of the battle, about one million men were killed, wounded or captured. The question remains however would the extra six weeks to prepare made a difference?

Douglas Haig – butcher or hero? By Rupert Colley

The Cabinet were mistaken, as most of the fodder was for the horses, donkeys and mules, which the BEF used to move supplies and heavy equipment. The problem of scale InBritain went to war with a small professional army. It is one of the criticisms levelled at Haig — that he was adverse to new technology.

Aeroplanes and tanks are only accessories to the men and the horse, and I feel sure that as time goes on you will find just as much use for the horse—the well-bred horse—as you have ever done in the past. David Lloyd George, prime minister of a coalition government from Decemberhad questioned the point of launching another costly offensive at Passchendaele but Haig had got the backing of the Conservatives within the coalition and so got his way.

The French took the lead in planning the offensive on the Western Front and Haig played second fiddle to commander-in-chief Joseph Joffre.

By the summer ofthe German attack at Verdun had left the French unable to commit forces on the scale they had envisioned. However Haig also rewrote his diary from this period, possibly to show himself in a better light and French in a poor one.

The plan The offensive on the Somme was initially conceived as part of a wider strategy to wear down the German Army by attacking it on all fronts in When told of this Joffre shouted at Haig that "the French Army would cease to exist" and had to be calmed down with "liberal doses of brandy".

The offensive ultimately led to victory and the surrender of the Germans on 11 November. The Cabinet were less optimistic and Kitchener like Rawlinson was also somewhat doubtful and would have preferred smaller and purely attritional attacks but sided with Robertson in telling the Cabinet that the Somme offensive should go ahead.

Haig was impressed and immediately ordered a thousand more. Haig had wanted to rest his corps but was happy to resume the offensive when ordered. This was just in time, as it later turned out that Petain at Verdun was warning the French government that the "game was up" unless the British attacked.

Only then did Haig accept an earldom. Haig was irritated by the high-handed behaviour of the French, seizing roads which they had promised for British use and refusing to promise to cover the British right flank.

But it was Haig who did much to help veterans.Was Haig a Butcher or War Winner? Words Jan 11th, 15 Pages Assessment- Interpretations of Haig (The battle of the Sommes was a notorious event that occurred in the time frame of World War I, between France and England on one side, while on the other side, Germany.

The negative reputation of Field Marshal Douglas Haig, the commander of British forces on the Western Front during World War One, rests to a. Douglas Haig, Britain’s First World War commander-in-chief from December to the end of the war, is remembered as the archetypal ‘donkey’.

Haig Deserving the Title of Butcher of the Somme Essay - Haig Deserving the Title of Butcher of the Somme Not entirely. Haig only deserves the title because he is the one who put ‘the plan’ into action. He fought a war of attrition with the support of Lloyd George.

(After the war was over, and even until now, Haig was regarded by many of the English (and global) society as being a ruthless soldier butcher, as he sent more than a million of lives to their tragic demise through one single plan. Was Haig a Butcher or War Winner? Words | 15 Pages.

Douglas Haig, 1st Earl Haig

Assessment- Interpretations of Haig (The battle of the Sommes was a notorious event that occurred in the time frame of World War I, between France and England on .

Download
Was haig a butcher or war
Rated 3/5 based on 66 review